Any legacy system is modernized after test migrations and pilots. They take weeks to complete and provide the validation needed before the go-ahead. We think everything in the full-scale transformation has happened seamlessly with no mistakes.
Yet, a record cannot be found five months in. An error that cannot be ignored shows up. A dependency that was supposed to have been there is now absent. You think these are all mistakes. They are actually the result of failing to create a proper legacy migration proof of concept.
A legacy migration POC is the first step towards modernizing your current tech stack in a planned manner. With a sound POC, your project is less likely to fail, be it due to data complexity, time, or budget.
According to Gartner, most data migration projects (83%) often fail or go over the planned timeline or budgets. Many of these would have succeeded at every stage of the process if there was a foolproof POC to follow.
If you are going for legacy system modernization and do not know of any method to create a proof of concept that lasts and delivers, let us be of assistance. This blog discusses ten compatibility tests to follow and the precautions you should take on the way.
What is a Legacy Migration Proof of Concept?
You know what a proof of concept (POC) is. You know it is performed as the first step of any technological innovation. However, have you ever considered it for your legacy transformation project?
A legacy migration proof of concept creates a modernization demonstration that uses a limited portion of the current system to conduct tests to figure out what will help and what will not in the target system. It is staged early (before a pilot completion), most usually as the first step towards transformation.
The best way to find out if a method can be utilized or a technology can be implemented is through a legacy migration POC. It negates any migration risks by validating the feasibility of the process before investing in full-scale modernization.
Many attempts at legacy migration often end in failure because they did an improper or rushed POC. The section below is a perfect example of all the tests your legacy migration proof of concept should conduct for a foolproof migration.
Legacy Migration Proof of Concept: 10 Compatibility Tests to Follow
When migrating your system from the legacy infrastructure to modern platforms, a viable new system/legacy application compatibility testing is necessary to ensure that every part of the legacy modernization path follows your plan. This includes the following ten tests across the process:
1. Test the Functional Parity of the Test Code and the Legacy Code
One of the first steps in legacy system POC testing is to conduct a characterization test. Use a representative set of data in the legacy as well as the target platform and provide the exact input to compare the output from both.
A lot of development teams do this test after migration; don’t make that mistake. Doing a functional parity test beforehand makes sure the ‘before’ and ‘after’ results match in outcome and logic. In other words, the new system should reproduce the exact output and recreate the same rules to maintain the parity expected.
2. Check the Data Migration and Integrity Throughout the Transfer
Most people do functional testing and forego data migration testing, without realizing that the system can still perform with incomplete or corrupted data even after a transfer. The only way to ensure that data formats, records, and relations remain intact is through a data migration test.
It is the best way to check whether all the data remains accurate, complete, and related to each other as before. The correctness of their referential integrity is especially useful to combat dependency complications.
3. Verify Pattern-Based Conversion Against the New System
A major portion of legacy migration proof of concept is the pattern-by-pattern conversion testing for the migration. You have to identify each legacy code pattern and test them in isolation for individual evaluations.
While testing the entire pattern library at once makes you feel like you saved time and effort, dependencies jumble up the code. Testing each pattern independently against the new system allows you to assess their behavior separately.
4. Check for Any Discrepancy That Needs to be Resolved
Any legacy system consists of several discrepancies or “special cases” where you know what the code does, but you do not exactly know the ‘how’ or ‘why’ of the errors. Such cases need to be fixed in the new system through legacy application compatibility testing to prevent any problems later.
You need to first identify these discrepancies and document them. Then you need to test corrective measures for each, without messing any of the patterns. The target system should be such that the same results are obtained, but with a clear, logical pathway for the ‘how’.
5. Do a Performance Benchmarking to Ensure Better Results
The purpose of any legacy system migration is to get better performance than before. Your legacy migration proof of concept should move towards that strategy. Instead of struggling to define clear criteria, be sure of what factors need to improve.
Measure elements like transaction throughput, latency, and resource usage in the target hardware or software. Make sure that the target system exceeds the legacy system performance or at least meets the baseline.
6. Test the External Interface Compatibility in the Target System
Every system, legacy or modern, interacts with several external interfaces that bring APIs, file transfers, message queues, etc. to complete a unified action. This needs to be redone with the new infrastructure as it was in the outdated system.
Basically, the integrations with the interfaces need to be such that their functionality is identical in the legacy and new environments. In short, the target system needs to rebuild the legacy application compatibility with these third parties.
7. Validate the Security and Compliance of the New System
Since you are migrating to a new system, you will now be able to meet the security policies and access control requirements necessary for your hardware or software. Methods like encryption and authentication should be present in the target system in your legacy migration proof of concept.
It must fight off the cyber threats commonly seen for your business that your legacy system had a hard time with, due to limited compatibility with modern security platforms. Compliance maintenance through processes such as audit logging are necessary too.
8. Maintain the UI and Workflow Consistency Throughout the Process
The usability and accessibility should be better in the target system compared to the legacy platform; it is the reason why non-technical employees passionately back the legacy migration POC in anticipation of an actual modernization.
The UI elements, navigation, and output formats should improve in the new system compared to the aging one, or at least remain consistent. While the end-user workflows should not change, their internal logic should improve with the same external flow.
9. Simulate Situations That Require Exception and Error Handling
Failures can happen at any time. Exceptions and errors can hit your system out of nowhere. Events like power or network outages, massive data corruption, cyberattacks, etc. can affect the system at any time.
The best way to ensure that the new system will work fine in these exceptional situations in your legacy migration proof of concept is to simulate these scenarios and ensure that it handles them better than, or at least as well as, the legacy system.
Did You Know? In the healthcare industry, 27% of US professionals notice errors due to aging technology daily, compared to 30% in the UK and 40% in Ireland, according to The HIPAA Journal (Presidio).
10. Measure Rollback and Recovery Readiness to the Legacy System
Define rollback triggers and procedures and test them thoroughly to detect their effects on hardware and software. Ensure that you can revert to legacy operations quickly and safely if the target system fails for any reason during the final migration.
The reversion should include a complete return of the legacy system through data restoration and service continuity without data loss. Keep in mind that, beyond the legacy migration proof of concept, a failure simulation must be done post-migration to ensure a successful recovery is possible.